Host a Horror Movie Night

Invite your bravest friends for a horror movie night! Scary movies are best when surrounded by other people. Horror connects all of us – no matter where you are from, we have all been afraid of what may lurk in the dark. Watching movies with friends allows you all to cower, laugh, and scream together. 

Ever since I was a freshman in college, I used to host movie night parties with my friends. I love to plan the perfect double-feature, meal, and activities to keep the fun going all night long. Here are a few of my tips for hosting an awesome horror movie night.

Pick Your Movie(s)

Single screening or double-feature? When you screen just one movie, anything can really work in the slot. For double-features, try to find films that share a theme or tonally work well together. I often will schedule the darker or more serious film first and save the funnier or more lively film second. That way they will be fresh and ready to experience the heavier film. Having the lighter film second will cleanse your pallet after the terror or darkness of the first film. Additionally, it helps to energize your crowd later in the evening, when they may be a little sleepy. 

My favorite movie nights feature campy horror – allowing us to riff on the film and laugh along. Other times it has been wonderful to share my favorite lesser-known horror films with my friends. It all depends on your taste. I love to introduce people to new movies they otherwise may not encounter.

Here are some pairings my friends rated among their favorites:

Invite Your Guests

Crafting the attendee list is a bit of an art. Here are a few of my guidelines for when I look for the right group of people for a party:

  • Send out invites early. Unlike me, my friends have active social lives, so they need to schedule it in their calendars.
  • If I intend to mix friends from different friend groups, I try to always make sure that each person knows at least one other person besides me at the party. This allows them to have someone they can talk to instantly while they are warming up to the rest of the group.
  • Think about who will actually enjoy the movies you are showing. Especially with horror, sometimes certain people will not do well with the movies you show. An animal lover might have a hard time watching Pet Sematary. A religious friend may not appreciate a movie with demonic possession.

Plan the Menu

Whether it just be popcorn and snacks or a full meal, plan your menu in advance. 

  • Have classic movie theater staples available: Popcorn, M&Ms, Skittles, and Soda
  • Match your meal to the movies. Do the films you show have certain featured foods? Try to incorporate them into the night’s menu. 
    • Try some Chinese takeout-inspired dishes with The Lost Boys
    • Spaghetti with homemade tomato sauce, bruschetta, and other tomato-based dishes compliment an Attack of the Killer Tomatoes double-feature. 
    • Check out The Horror Movie Night Cookbook by Richard S Sargent for some other pairing ideas.
  • Make sure to have enough food for all. General guidelines advise to make about 4-6 oz of your main protein, 4-6 oz of your sides, 2 oz of bread or starch, and 1-2 servings of dessert per person. You should also add about a 10% buffer in case you have a particularly ravenous friend (or the unexpected guest arrives). 
  • Be sure to ask ahead if any guests have allergies or dietary needs. If so, be sure to mark allergens and/or safe-to-eat foods so guests can choose their items with care. 
  • Remember food safety! Non-shelf stable foods should not be sitting out all evening. Keep warmers on hand or refrigerate leftovers to prevent food-borne illnesses. 

Plan Fun Activities

Yes, they all came for the movies, but a few fun activities are what will help your group bond and decompress after a scary movie. I love to have a few party games on hand to help people mix and mingle before, after, an/or in-between the films. Here are some of my friends’ favorites:

  • Horror Movie Trivia – Try the Horror Movie edition of Trivial Pursuit, or the horror-themed “Murder Party” Jackbox games
  • Drinking Games – Let guests take shots (or mocktail shots for teetotalers like me) based on criteria matched to your films.
    • Sip for each jump scare
    • Sip when a ghost or monster appears
    • Sip when a horror trope occurs
  • Arts & Crafts
    • During our Attack of the Killer Tomatoes double-feature, my guests decorated their own pet tomato to take home. 
    • Guests can make their own killer masks for screenings of The Purge films, The Strangers films, or other slashers.
    • When in season, carve pumpkins to accompany Halloween-themed films.
  • Board & Card Games – There are a bunch of horror themed games to set the mood.
    • Last Night on Earth (Zombies)
    • Horrified (Universal Monsters)
    • Final Girl (Various Horror Tropes)
    • Official Film Adaptations: Halloween, Scream: The Game, The Texas Chainsaw Massacre Board Game, Chucky, The Thing, and many more
    • Werewolf (Various Versions)
    • Campy Creatures (B-horror monsters)

Enjoy Your Horror Movie Night

You’ve done the planning, cleaned your house, made the food, set up the games, and now the guests are arriving. It is time to enjoy all your efforts and have a wonderful movie night.

Want some suggestions for a mini movie marathon? Check out some of my favorite horror shorts in my Film Friday blog post series:

Host a Horror Movie Night

Invite your bravest friends for a horror movie night! Scary movies are best when surrounded by other people. Horror connects all of us – no matter where you are from,

Read More »

Apple Pie Recipe

Make a homemade apple pie with Emily’s special sweet crust recipe. This classic is sure to be a hit at your next spooky gathering!

Read More »

Halloween Divination Games

According to legends of yore, Halloween night is the time when the veil between the living and spirit worlds is the thinnest. This not only means that you may see

Read More »